Alright, we are at the point in our Dragon Theories series where we have covered every species, and now all that is left are the hybrids revealed to us in Dragons: Titan Uprising! There are 5 of these: the Abomibumble (Monstrous Nightmare x Gronckle), the Hushbogle (Whispering Death x Snow Wraith), the Ghastly Zapplejack (Hideous Zippleback x Timberjack), the Deathly Galeslash (Deadly Nadder x Stormcutter), and the Brooding Boltstamper (Rumblehorn x Skrill). But before we talk about hybrids, I do want to cover both facts about real hybrids in nature and also theories about how the HTTYD hybrids might work in general terms before we get to these five specific types.
But in order to talk about hybrids, we must talk about two slightly varying definition of hybrids in biology. First, we need to define "hybrid."
Hybrid definition: the offspring of two different varieties of organisms
These varieties are often thought of as different species, but they could also refer to, say, different subspecies. A Night Light - a cross between a Night Fury and Light Fury - is a hybrid, regardless of whether or not it's one species or a mix of two different species. (A Night Fury and a Light Fury are typically depicted as two varieties of the same species but sometimes are described as different species because...DreamWorks gets confused sometimes, I don't know.) So before we get into hybrids between different species, I do briefly want to cover potential hybrids between different subspecies, all of which are completely possible within the franchise. I made a list of possibilities! ...It's a big list.
Potential Subspecies Hybrids:
Night Fury Species:
Night Fury/Light Fury a.k.a. Night Light (the only natural hybrid seen in the franchise outside of Dragons: Titan Uprising)
Monstrous Nightmare Species:
Monstrous Nightmare/Merciful Nightmare
Monstrous Nightmare/Mountain Nightmare
Merciful Nightmare/Mountain Nightmare
Deadly Nadder Species:
Brush Nadder/Nimble Nadder
Gronckle Species:
Common Gronckle/Grove Gronckle
Common Gronckle/Gentle Gronckle
Grove Gronckle/Gentle Gronckle
Hideous Zippleback Species:
Hideous Zippleback/Valley Zippleback
Hideous Zippleback/Zesty Zippleback
Valley Zippleback/Zesty Zippleback
Terrible Terror Species:
Terrible Terror/Garden Dragon
Timberjack Species:
Common Timberjack/Tricky Timberjack
Common Timberjack/Wetland Timberjack
Tricky Timberjack/Wetland Timberjack
Thunderdrum Species:
Common Thunderdrum/Reef Thunderdrum
Common Thunderdrum/Tectonic Thunderdrum
Reef Thunderdrum/Tectonic Thunderdrum
Stormcutter Species:
Common Stormcutter/Woodland Stormcutter
Common Stormcutter/Serene Stormcutter
Woodland Stormcutter/Serene Stormcutter
Rumblehorn Species:
Common Rumblehorn/Arctic Rumblehorn
Common Rumblehorn/Robust Rumblehorn
Arctic Rumblehorn/Robust Rumblehorn
Snafflefang Species:
Common Snafflefang/Slough Snafflefang
Common Snafflefang/Stocky Snafflefang
Slouch Snafflefang/Stocky Snafflefang
Scuttleclaw Species:
Scuttleclaw/Budbite
Snifflehunch Species:
Snifflehunch/Sneezlehunch
Whispering Death Species:
Common Whispering Death/Brisk Whisper
Common Whispering Death/Guarded Whisper
Brisk Whisper/Guarded Whisper
Boneknapper Species:
Boneknapper/Grave Knapper
Boneknapper/Bludgeon Knapper
Grave Knapper/Bludgeon Knapper
Skrill Species:
Marshland Skrill/Shadow Skrill
Snaptrapper Species:
Common Snaptrapper/Leafy Snaptrapper
Speed Stinger Species:
Common Speed Stinger/Webbed-Footed Speed Stinger
Typhoomerang Species:
Common Typhoomerang/Forest Typhoomerang
Common Typhoomerang/Tense Typhoomerang
Forest Typhoomerang/Tense Typhoomerang
Snow Wraith Species:
Snow Wraith/Wood Wraith
Snow Wraith/Wild Wraith
Wood Wraith/Wild Wraith
Slithersong Species:
Slithersong/Death Song
Night Terror Species:
Night Terror/Night Swarm
Night Terror/Fire Terror
Night Terror/Heartwarmer
Night Swarm/Fire Terror
Night Swarm/Heartwarmer
Fire Terror/Heartwarmer
Small Shadow Wing Species:
Small Shadow/Sunchaser
Small Shadow/Shadechaser
Sunchase/Shadechaser
Rockstomper Species:
Common Rockstomper/Moldruffle
Groncicle Species:
Common Groncicle/Frozen Groncicle
Sand Wraith Species:
Sand Wraith/Desert Wraith
Sand Wraith/Sweet Wraith
Desert Wraith/Sweet Wraith
Woolly Howl Species:
Woolly Howl/Snoggletog Wraith
So that's all the subspecies hybrids that are possible, but that will produce a dragon of the same species that will be able to breed itself and will not change too drastically, since its parents are so similar. The hybrids from Dragons: Titan Uprising are crosses between two different species. Because of this, that is what our following theories and facts will be focused on.
Theories and Facts on Multi-Species Hybrids
Theory 1: Size effects hybridization. Dragons will not hybridize if there is a huge size difference. This seems obvious, but yes, this means that there are certain crosses that just can't happen. Bewilderbeasts with Stormcutters. Terrible Terrors with Monstrous Nightmares. Smothering Smokebreaths with Deadly Nadders. Heck, I even left out the crossing of the two Prickleboggle subspecies when listing subspecies hybrids because the size difference is just too great.
Theory 2: The known hybrids are infertile. By "known hybrids," I do mean the ones in Dragons: Titan Uprising: the Abomibumble (Monstrous Nightmare/Gronckle), Hushbogle (Whispering Death/Snow Wraith), Ghastly Zapplejack (Hideous Zippleback/Timberjack), Deathly Galeslash (Deadly Nadder/Stormcutter), and Brooding Boltstamper (Skrill/Rumblehorn). While these can all breed in the game because of how game mechanics work, I don't think that would actually be the case. These species are so different that, even if these hybrids can exist in this universe, there's no way they could breed themselves. They would be infertile, like mules.
(Again, since Night Lights are most likely a subspecies hybrid, not a mix of different species, they don't apply here. Those should be fertile.)
Theory 3: Hybrid dragons tend to behave more like their mother's species. Typically when you have a hybrid animal, the question of whether it will behave more like one parent or the other always comes up. Will a wolfdog be more wolf or dog? Will a mule act more like a horse or a donkey? Is a liger more like a tiger or a lion in behavior? There's no strict rule here; different individuals will lean more toward one species or another just based on chance genetics. But there is a trend that can help us predict the species a hybrid will be more like. Whether wild or (more often) captively bred, hybrids tend to behave a little more like the species of whatever parent raises them, which is typically the mother. This is because, though genes make up a good bit of our behavior, so does nurture, and the mother raising the offspring is of course going to teach it to act like herself and her own kind. So my theory here is that dragons, being nurturing animals where mothers seem to do most of the raising, are very much the same. The hybrid in question, no matter what type, is more likely to lean toward whichever species that actually raises it, typically its mother's species. For example, the Abomibumble who has a Nightmare mother might be a little less inclined to sleep all day than the Abomibumble with a Gronckle mother, even if they both have a bit of natural laziness compared to a pure Nightmare and more energy than a pure Gronckle.
Theory 4: Fire-breathing is ancestral and will dominate other firepowers genetically in hybrids. This applies to any hypothetical hybrids as opposed to the Titan Uprising ones specifically; those in the game already have their firepower types stated. But it is interesting that, when dragons are crossed in the game, fire never seems to go away. The Abomibumble - a combination of fire and lava firepowers - and the Brooding Boltstamper - a combination of fiery rock and lightning firepowers - ended up shooting lava rather than fire, but they still have that fire heat. Meanwhile, the Ghastly Zapplejack kept the Timberjack's fire type entirely, replacing their Zippleback spark that they use to light their gas with the fire instead, and the Hushbogle, which combines fire and ice, shows no hint of ice ever being in the lineage, simply shooting fire in a Snow Wraith-styled shot. When combined with an earth-based fire like lava, there is a tendency to have a lava-based fire, but the heat of fire is still there, and when combining fire with water, fire comes out on top.
And this is no surprise: fire is the most common breath weapon, more so than water or acid or electricity or plasma or anything else of that sort. It is found in every dragon class, and in most classes, it is the most popular fire type. This makes me believe it is the ancestral breath weapon of all dragons, the most ancient of all of them, which means even the frostiest ice breathers might have the hidden genes necessary for fire-breathing. As a result, when the two gene sequences of very different species are crossed, the ability for a more derived firepower might be lost but the ability to breathe fire can usually survive the crossing. I'd say that if you cross a fire-breathing dragon with a water-breathing one, you're either going to get fire or boiling water. With an acid breather, you could get flaming acid or simply fire. No matter what, fire or at least the heat of it will come through the cross.
Theory 5: Night Furies cannot mate with dragons outside their species. Yeah, so...this is basically an explanation as to why, when I list possible multi-species mixes, I'm not including Night Furies. Or Light Furies, for that matter. I do think of both Furies as the same species, just different subspecies, because that's what the franchise claims the most often, so this theory applies to both Fury dragons. Basically, I don't think Furies can mate outside of their species, and the reason has to do with the plot of Hidden World. If Toothless could have found a mate among any other dragon, that weakens his need to find and be with the Light Fury, a need which is a necessary component of the last movie's story.
And yes, this includes Sand Wraiths or Woolly Howls. I don't think Furies could mate with either of these dragons. At least, not in nature; I don't know if artificial insemination would work here, but the point is, Toothless isn't going to be actively pursuing any other dragons. And the reasons could be genetic, but they could also just be behavioral. Perhaps Furies are super picky and simply won't hybridize. Or maybe these dragons differ too much in mating strategies to want to cross. I've also stated that I don't think either Sand Wraiths or Woolly Howls mate for life - in fact, I've said that most dragons don't mate for life - and Night Furies definitely do, which makes them distinct in their mating strategy and may enhance their pickiness and insistence on having a mate of their own kind. After all, it's one thing to have a fling with a different species when you know you can look for some other guy to get together with next year, but when you're looking for a life partner, you'll probably have higher standards. So that also could be a deterrent.
Just because a dragon's genomes are compatible doesn't mean their behavior will be. But whether it's the behavior or the genes or a combination thereof, Furies just aren't interested in getting together with non-Fury partners. Sorry, Fury hybrid OC owners. But hey, don't change your OC on my account.
Theory 6: Dragons who's mainstay food is other dragons do not hybridize with other dragons. This includes Deathgrippers, Slithersongs, Death Songs, Grim Gnashers, and Scauldrons. Now again, this is assuming we're talking about two dragons naturally choosing to mate with each other, not any form of artificial insemination. I do think some of these dragons might have compatible genomes with other dragons; I do wonder if the Deathgripper and Triple Stryke share a relationship, for example. But I just don't think dragon eaters are going to naturally hybridize. The reason is that they eat other dragons and so would view them as food, not something to socialize with and get together with. Mating with your food is not something animals do...typically.
Theory 7: Sentinels do not naturally hybridize because they do not interact with potential mating partners of other species. Alright, so here's another dragon that I won't consider for natural hybridization, this time because of where they live. Sentinels live on Vanaheim and guard the dragon dead. The only dragons that ever visit their home island are predator dragons like Grim Gnashers and possibly bone snatchers like Boneknappers - both of which Sentinels are in conflict with - and dragons who are dying. No healthy, compatible species is going to come in proximity with them under any normal circumstances, so it's unlikely that they would ever have a chance to choose a mate not their own.
Theory 8: Slitherwings cannot hybridize because of their poison. Finally, there's one last dragon I'm eliminating from the potential of ever having hybrids in this franchise: Slitherwings. And the reason is obvious. Touching them is deadly, so any dragon who tried to get together with one would just suffer a terrible fate. Too bad for the Slitherwing; I'm sure it has a charming personality when it wants to. XD
The reason I'm not including Threadtails in this is that you may recall in my Threadtail theories that I believed Threadtails are not secreting poison all the time but only do so when they feel they need to. You can see my Threadtail theories
here to see my reason.
Theory 9: Possible Hybrid Breeding Groups (not including Dragons: Titan Uprising hybrid groups): Alright, so before we get on to confirmed hybrids, I want to take one last look at some hypothetical hybrids. Here, I'm basically going to name groups of dragons that I think might possibly have the ability to interbreed with each other and then explain my reasoning. I will not be including dragons I think are in the hybrid groups that include the Titan Uprising hybrids because I'm going to cover those in the individual hybrids' posts. So with that said, what other dragons do I think might be possible to hybridize, assuming the TU hybrids are in fact canon?
Terrible Terror and Night Terror: My reasoning for these two being able to hybridize is pretty straightforward: they are similar in size enough for it to work, and the franchise outright states that these two are relatives. So if a Nightmare and a Gronckle can get together, I'd assume that Terrible Terror and Night Terror would make a fine couple. They are even both pack dragons, so even socialization might not be a big problem. And there's 2 different subspecies of Terrible Terror and 4 different subspecies of Night Terror to choose from, so there's a lot of possibilities here!
I also wouldn't be against the Smothering Smokebreath and Hobgobbler being in this group, but I'm a little hesitant to include them just because there's no real indication of close relationship there aside from similar size.
Hobblegrunt, Threadtail, Thornridge, Devilish Dervish, Giant Prickleboggle, Windstriker, Raincutter, Shivertooth, and Razorwhip: Yes, I think all of these dragons might have the ability to hybridize with each other. This is mainly due to the fact that they all have a fairly similar body plan, with many of them resembling theropod dinosaurs and having very much the same features of this theropod body and stance with long necks, tails, and snouts. The Shivertooth and Razorwhip are the outliers here, as they quadruped dragons rather than biped and tend toward a narrower body type, but they are still close enough that they could very well mingle in this breeding group, I think.
One thing I want to note here is that, with the Prickleboggle, I did say Giant Prickleboggle. The common Prickleboggle is too small to mate with any of these dragons, including its own giant cousin.
Rockstomper, Shovelhelm, Snifflehunch, Windgnasher, Snafflefang, Thunderclaw, and Mudraker: The reasoning here is the same as the last group. These dragons all have a similar body plan, enough that I think they should be closely-related enough to produce offspring together. (You might recall from my Rockstomper theories that I consider the Moldruffle a type of Rockstomper, hence why it's not individually listed here, but it's included, too.)
Tide Glider and Sliquifier: What's so interesting about these dragons is that, if we look at the original versions of both of them, they both have two wings, two front limbs in the form of flippers, and no back limbs. (The Tide Glider has 2 different versions and the Sliquifier has 3, all with different limb plans, but in this case we're going with the movie Sliquifier and the Rise of Berk Tide Glider.) This similar body plan makes me believe that these dragons share a similar aquatic lineage and therefore just might be able to hybridize.
Now the Seashocker also has this limb design, but the reason I didn't include it is because the franchise claimed its closest relative is the electric eel. Which doesn't really make sense, but...eh.
Changewing and Dramillion: I have no idea why the franchise decided these two were relatives aside from plot convenience, but they are canonically relatives. Again, if a Gronckle can mate with a Monstrous Nightmare...why not?
Boneknapper, Armorwing, and Sword Stealer: Boneknappers, Armorwings, and Sword Stealers not only tend to have very similar habits (making a coat of armor out of scraps) but also have very similar body plans. For this reason, I do think they could hybridize. It's hard to say what hybrids are more likely: Armorwings and Sword Stealers are probably more closely related, but Sword Stealers and Boneknappers appear to be closer in size. Nevertheless, I think any combination here could work, if the dragons are willing.
Alright, athat's all the theories I have on multi-species hybrids for this franchise, both for the established 5 and for hypothetical ones. But before I close, here's a few facts that I know for sure about our hybrids:
Fact 1: Hybrid eggs look like the eggs of their mother's species. So many times I see people depict the eggs of hybrids as being a mixture like the hybrid itself, but it's not. The egg will look like the egg of the mother's species. This is because eggs - of any type of any creature - are made by the mother's body and reflect her genetics. They are not made by the genes of the baby. So if a Nadder has mated with a Stormcutter, her egg will look like any other Nadder egg. You won't know her egg actually contains a Deathly Galeslash until it hatches. Surprise!
Fact 2: Hybrids often experience hybrid vigor, also called "heterosis." This is a very important detail when trying to figure out the strength and power of hybrids. Hybrid vigor, or heterosis, is described as "the tendency of a crossbred individual to show qualities superior to those of both parents." This increased "vigor" goes for both subspecies crosses and species crosses. The heterosis will often reveal itself in the animal being potentially bigger and stronger in stature, having a faster growth rate, and being less susceptible to disease. If it's a fertile subspecies hybrid, it might also have increased fertility. The science behind why this happens is not well-understood, but it is a widely-observed phenomenon. This is something to take into account when writing about hybrid characters or, you know, making theories about hybrids.
Fact 3: Hybrids are canonically extremely rare in the wild in this franchise. Also, real reptiles do hybridize, much more commonly than many people give them credit for. Yes, I consider the fact that dragon hybrids are rare to be confirmed canon. Not only have we not seen any natural hybrids outside of
Titan Uprising and maybe in
Hidden World with the Night Lights, but also
Titan Uprising outright states that wild dragons don't usually hybridize (which is why it's a plot point in the game that more of them are popping up, indicating there's a type of disturbance happening in these dragons' populations because of the villains in the game).
If I'm quite honest, I was going to make this a theory before research concluded that it is indeed canon. Still, I do want to go into detail here. Why might hybrids be rare?
To answer that question, we first need to ask, "Why aren't they rare?" and also, "Could they even exist, and why would they exist?" And answering these questions has led me to realize that...I don't think a lot of people in the fandom are aware of the real science of reptilian hybrids. I've seen a lot of people in the HTTYD fandom saying things like, "Reptile hybrids are unheard-of and putting them in HTTYD is wrong and the Night Lights are unbelievable." And these people are wrong...well, you know, they're wrong about the "reptile hybrids" part, the rest is opinion.
So first, to defend Night Lights here. As mentioned before, the Night Fury and Light Fury are most likely the same species, just distinct subspecies, so the Night Light is just a subspecies cross, like a wolfdog. I personally think the Night Lights look utterly ridiculous from a biological standpoint - why in the world are they piebald? - but their existence does follow real-world logic.
But even putting that aside, multi-species hybrids are not as uncommon in nature as many seem to think, depending on the type of organism. Plants, for example, hybridize pretty often compared to us animals and are less likely to have detrimental effects from this. But since dragons are animals, specifically vertebrates, we should probably look at vertebrate hybrids. Even then, there seems to be more hybrids in the world than people realize.
When vertebrates hybridize successfully, they are normally in the same genus. Reptiles - which is what dragons are said to be - actually commonly have "hybrid zones" when two species of the same genus have overlapping territories if the two species are close enough to in relation to produce fertile offspring. In these hybrid zones, lizards may be any percentage of one species or another, since all these lizards are breeding at random. So actually, hybridization is relatively common in healthy reptile populations with closely-related species. Saying that hybrid reptiles are unheard-of is just incorrect. They're just not trumpeted as much as mammalian hybrids are in captivity, so we rarely get to see them. You'll be hard-pressed to buy or breed a hybrid pet reptile, but that doesn't mean there are no recorded cases of reptilian hybrids.
But of course, when talking about hybrid zones, we're usually talking about lizards and snakes. That's less so the case with crocodilians and birds, which are the reptiles I personally believe dragons would be most closely related to if they existed. If dragons were real-world reptiles, I believe they would be archosaurs, just like crocodilians, pterosaurs, and dinosaurs (including birds), and such animals are far less likely to have natural hybrid zones. Much like mammals, however, birds and crocodilians will interbreed with other species when they have trouble finding a mate within their own species. For example, due to the decline of Cuban crocodiles (there's only an estimated 4,000 left), they have recently begun interbreeding with American crocodiles since they have trouble finding mates of their own kind. As for birds, as many as 10% of the 10,000 bird species on the planet have been recorded producing hybrids, and while some of these were captive, many were not. Nevertheless, it is important to note that hybrids for these animals are far more likely in captivity for a few reasons: 1) animals may find a lack of mates of their own species simply because they are not allowed to roam to find them and so mate with whoever is available in their enclosure, or 2) humans intentionally set up a situation in order to produce a hybrid (as is often the case with ligers and mules).
Still, even with hybrids being far more possible and common than I often see people give them credit for, they are still rare overall compare to pure species. (Separate species wouldn't be "separate" otherwise.) And the more distant the species are from each other, the less likely you'll find a hybrid. Fertile hybrids do sometimes create small "hybrid zones," but if the species are so different that the hybrid is born infertile, then they are even rarer in wild settings because they can't be multi-generational.
So putting all this together, it both makes sense that the HTTYD world might have a few hybrids but that they are rare. Generally species are going to stick with their own kind when their own kind is available, especially if the species around them are too different to produce fertile offspring. In HTTYD, we see that many of the hybrids produced are either produced by subspecies already in the same species or they are produced by individuals so different that they are likely to be infertile, so you're not even going to have hybrids for more than one generation. They happen, they're possible, but they're not common at all. Exactly like what we see with real birds and real crocodilians.
Now do I think the specific type of hybrids seen in Titan Uprising make sense? Not at all! When I first thought of believable hybrids in this franchise, I was thinking about crosses like a Gronckle/Hotburple cross, not a Gronckle/Nightmare cross. That's pretty outlandish and definitely taking leniency from fiction. But the theory behind it does actually check out.
And so that's an overview of my thoughts on hybrids and potential hybrid groups in the franchise and also just some basic facts about dragon hybrids and real-world hybrids in general. It's mostly just a post to answer the big questions before I get to specific hybrids. But I am interested in hearing what people might have to add or if they want to reshuffle or add to any of my potential breeding groups. Knock yourselves out.
Okay, my next Dragon Theories post will be on a particular hybrid from
Dragons: Titan Uprising, the Brooding Boltstamper (Skrill/Rumblehorn cross)! I don't know what the format will be for the hybrids quite yet and what all the questions are that I'll be trying to answer for each of them, but I suppose the Brooding Boltstamper is now my test subject. And that post will be out as soon as possible, hopefully tomorrow, so keep an eye out for it!